{ "version": "wq.result/1", "scoringVersion": "wq.scoring/3", "caseId": "constrained-001-meeting-v3", "runId": "2026-09-16T12-41-18-021Z-planner-regression", "mode": "planner", "status": "UNRESOLVED", "metrics": { "parse_success": true, "semantic_plan_valid": true, "requested_rooms_created": true, "requested_room_count_preserved": true, "requested_objects_present": true, "topology_valid": true, "portals_usable": true, "circulation_valid": true, "objects_grounded": true, "major_collisions": 0, "collision_scope": "independent resolved all-pairs geometry", "requested_relations_satisfied": true, "requested_dimensions_preserved": null, "constraints_not_certified": [ "per-seat presentation visibility", "per-seat egress clearance" ], "constraints_dropped": null, "required_program_obligations_satisfied": false, "required_program_obligations": 9, "structured_programs_preserved": true, "structured_constraints_dropped": 0, "constraint_preservation_scope": "Exact multiset of accepted structured RoomProgram intents; not a proof of natural-language completeness", "semantic_enrichment_repairs": [ { "room": "7de3cdec-20ec-4f7a-9f71-d93e99b46b10", "record": { "stage": "semantic", "attempts": 1, "strategy": "none", "initialFailures": [], "finalState": "accepted", "relaxedConstraints": [] } } ], "semantic_interpretation_repair": { "stage": "semantic", "attempts": 1, "strategy": "none", "initialFailures": [], "finalState": "accepted", "relaxedConstraints": [] }, "deterministic_layout_searches": [ { "room": "7de3cdec-20ec-4f7a-9f71-d93e99b46b10", "record": { "policy": "qway.room-program-layout/1", "strategy": "bounded-geometric-search", "candidateBudget": 2048, "candidatesTested": 1560, "passesPerformed": 3, "initialRules": [ { "reference": "seat_meeting_seats", "status": "unknown" }, { "reference": "circulation_access", "status": "unsupported" }, { "reference": "access_meeting_surface", "status": "unsupported" }, { "reference": "access_meeting_seats", "status": "unsupported" }, { "reference": "explicit_relation_d90f93605e9e652b1dd83bf8", "status": "unknown" } ], "changedInstances": [ "365298ad-7d53-44cc-8178-0d8276a168d7", "4a4a5291-4ac4-4ca5-9e0f-002207a7c46d", "5ea849ea-af5b-4d96-b17d-70c340d8b2a3", "669d43bb-e49f-49f2-abdb-d7f67f416589", "683145f0-09b0-4eeb-8b9a-651366bdfa3f", "766c8093-5e43-4d8e-b00b-3f2c965d487c", "83cd351f-0f82-4e0c-a1bb-59e4cc915115", "cc88a642-8dc3-4859-bda0-f023225a1e23", "de853a51-d6dd-4349-8516-2e755a1bb085", "e64d2b6d-e4c1-4ae3-862a-6f94df6f7da2" ], "relaxedConstraints": [], "termination": "stationary" } } ], "declared_relaxations": [], "repair_count": null, "repair_telemetry": "Semantic interpretation/enrichment attempts and deterministic candidates are separate records when available; no invented aggregate unit", "visual_capture_success": true, "visual_review": "pending", "rendered_objects": 18, "room_count": 1, "unknown_collision_pairs": 6 }, "missingRooms": [], "missingObjects": [], "missingNeeds": [], "unverifiedProgramObligations": [ { "room": "7de3cdec-20ec-4f7a-9f71-d93e99b46b10", "reference": "circulation_access", "field": "rules", "kind": "circulation", "priority": "required", "required": true, "status": "unknown", "evidence": { "reference": "circulation_access", "kind": "circulation", "priority": "required", "strength": "hard", "status": "unknown", "message": "Some requested units or entrance routes remain unverified; no constraints were discarded", "pairs": [ { "subject": "365298ad-7d53-44cc-8178-0d8276a168d7", "target": null, "status": "satisfied", "message": "Verified conservative actor route to the policy-defined use approach; not manipulation, seat-height or full ergonomic certification", "residuals": { "routeLengthM": 3.565949719705484, "actorRadiusM": 0.25, "actorHeightM": 1.8 } }, { "subject": "669d43bb-e49f-49f2-abdb-d7f67f416589", "target": null, "status": "satisfied", "message": "Verified conservative actor route to the policy-defined use approach; not manipulation, seat-height or full ergonomic certification", "residuals": { "routeLengthM": 5.413950074509542, "actorRadiusM": 0.25, "actorHeightM": 1.8 } }, { "subject": "5ea849ea-af5b-4d96-b17d-70c340d8b2a3", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} }, { "subject": "683145f0-09b0-4eeb-8b9a-651366bdfa3f", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} }, { "subject": "766c8093-5e43-4d8e-b00b-3f2c965d487c", "target": null, "status": "satisfied", "message": "Verified conservative actor route to the policy-defined use approach; not manipulation, seat-height or full ergonomic certification", "residuals": { "routeLengthM": 3.9799390183184746, "actorRadiusM": 0.25, "actorHeightM": 1.8 } }, { "subject": "cc88a642-8dc3-4859-bda0-f023225a1e23", "target": null, "status": "satisfied", "message": "Verified conservative actor route to the policy-defined use approach; not manipulation, seat-height or full ergonomic certification", "residuals": { "routeLengthM": 1.7605731307779922, "actorRadiusM": 0.25, "actorHeightM": 1.8 } }, { "subject": "e64d2b6d-e4c1-4ae3-862a-6f94df6f7da2", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} }, { "subject": "83cd351f-0f82-4e0c-a1bb-59e4cc915115", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} }, { "subject": "4a4a5291-4ac4-4ca5-9e0f-002207a7c46d", "target": null, "status": "satisfied", "message": "Verified conservative actor route to the policy-defined use approach; not manipulation, seat-height or full ergonomic certification", "residuals": { "routeLengthM": 0.32870320191818736, "actorRadiusM": 0.25, "actorHeightM": 1.8 } } ] } }, { "room": "7de3cdec-20ec-4f7a-9f71-d93e99b46b10", "reference": "access_meeting_seats", "field": "rules", "kind": "access", "priority": "required", "required": true, "status": "unknown", "evidence": { "reference": "access_meeting_seats", "kind": "access", "priority": "required", "strength": "hard", "status": "unknown", "message": "Some requested units or entrance routes remain unverified; no constraints were discarded", "pairs": [ { "subject": "669d43bb-e49f-49f2-abdb-d7f67f416589", "target": null, "status": "satisfied", "message": "Verified conservative actor route to the policy-defined use approach; not manipulation, seat-height or full ergonomic certification", "residuals": { "routeLengthM": 5.413950074509542, "actorRadiusM": 0.25, "actorHeightM": 1.8 } }, { "subject": "5ea849ea-af5b-4d96-b17d-70c340d8b2a3", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} }, { "subject": "683145f0-09b0-4eeb-8b9a-651366bdfa3f", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} }, { "subject": "766c8093-5e43-4d8e-b00b-3f2c965d487c", "target": null, "status": "satisfied", "message": "Verified conservative actor route to the policy-defined use approach; not manipulation, seat-height or full ergonomic certification", "residuals": { "routeLengthM": 3.9799390183184746, "actorRadiusM": 0.25, "actorHeightM": 1.8 } }, { "subject": "cc88a642-8dc3-4859-bda0-f023225a1e23", "target": null, "status": "satisfied", "message": "Verified conservative actor route to the policy-defined use approach; not manipulation, seat-height or full ergonomic certification", "residuals": { "routeLengthM": 1.7605731307779922, "actorRadiusM": 0.25, "actorHeightM": 1.8 } }, { "subject": "e64d2b6d-e4c1-4ae3-862a-6f94df6f7da2", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} }, { "subject": "83cd351f-0f82-4e0c-a1bb-59e4cc915115", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} }, { "subject": "4a4a5291-4ac4-4ca5-9e0f-002207a7c46d", "target": null, "status": "satisfied", "message": "Verified conservative actor route to the policy-defined use approach; not manipulation, seat-height or full ergonomic certification", "residuals": { "routeLengthM": 0.32870320191818736, "actorRadiusM": 0.25, "actorHeightM": 1.8 } } ] } } ], "programPreservation": [ { "reference": "new_meeting_room", "room": "7de3cdec-20ec-4f7a-9f71-d93e99b46b10", "status": "preserved" } ], "failedRelations": [], "warnings": [ { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 325, "end": 633, "line": 4, "column": 1 }, "identity": "57ff1a84-d6fe-4b50-9080-a1d88ea4f3b7", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 325, "end": 633, "line": 4, "column": 1 }, "identity": "57ff1a84-d6fe-4b50-9080-a1d88ea4f3b7", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 842, "end": 1127, "line": 6, "column": 1 }, "identity": "365298ad-7d53-44cc-8178-0d8276a168d7", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 1128, "end": 1413, "line": 7, "column": 1 }, "identity": "669d43bb-e49f-49f2-abdb-d7f67f416589", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 1414, "end": 1699, "line": 8, "column": 1 }, "identity": "5ea849ea-af5b-4d96-b17d-70c340d8b2a3", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 1700, "end": 1985, "line": 9, "column": 1 }, "identity": "683145f0-09b0-4eeb-8b9a-651366bdfa3f", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 1986, "end": 2271, "line": 10, "column": 1 }, "identity": "766c8093-5e43-4d8e-b00b-3f2c965d487c", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 2272, "end": 2557, "line": 11, "column": 1 }, "identity": "cc88a642-8dc3-4859-bda0-f023225a1e23", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 2558, "end": 2843, "line": 12, "column": 1 }, "identity": "e64d2b6d-e4c1-4ae3-862a-6f94df6f7da2", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 2844, "end": 3129, "line": 13, "column": 1 }, "identity": "83cd351f-0f82-4e0c-a1bb-59e4cc915115", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 3130, "end": 3415, "line": 14, "column": 1 }, "identity": "4a4a5291-4ac4-4ca5-9e0f-002207a7c46d", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 3416, "end": 3709, "line": 15, "column": 1 }, "identity": "de853a51-d6dd-4349-8516-2e755a1bb085", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 3416, "end": 3709, "line": 15, "column": 1 }, "identity": "de853a51-d6dd-4349-8516-2e755a1bb085", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 3710, "end": 4002, "line": 16, "column": 1 }, "identity": "b5903fde-aec2-4a3c-a984-49d67822a37f", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 3710, "end": 4002, "line": 16, "column": 1 }, "identity": "b5903fde-aec2-4a3c-a984-49d67822a37f", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "SIZE_CLASSIFICATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "Sizing retained conservative measured dimensions; inspect profile confidence and dimension reference", "span": { "start": 3710, "end": 4002, "line": 16, "column": 1 }, "identity": "b5903fde-aec2-4a3c-a984-49d67822a37f", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 4003, "end": 4303, "line": 17, "column": 1 }, "identity": "4810f59e-745b-4c70-bacf-5733a90a76b5", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 4003, "end": 4303, "line": 17, "column": 1 }, "identity": "4810f59e-745b-4c70-bacf-5733a90a76b5", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 4304, "end": 4605, "line": 18, "column": 1 }, "identity": "db60a0da-6034-48f7-8e09-b8fc5b9af7f6", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 4304, "end": 4605, "line": 18, "column": 1 }, "identity": "db60a0da-6034-48f7-8e09-b8fc5b9af7f6", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 4606, "end": 4906, "line": 19, "column": 1 }, "identity": "2793b5bb-1571-4723-ab7e-c92162833228", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 4606, "end": 4906, "line": 19, "column": 1 }, "identity": "2793b5bb-1571-4723-ab7e-c92162833228", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 4907, "end": 5278, "line": 20, "column": 1 }, "identity": "1e5a3095-17ba-4318-802b-8717665ee000", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 4907, "end": 5278, "line": 20, "column": 1 }, "identity": "1e5a3095-17ba-4318-802b-8717665ee000", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 5279, "end": 5651, "line": 21, "column": 1 }, "identity": "6d15a93b-fb75-4f76-aa71-85bee08af864", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 5279, "end": 5651, "line": 21, "column": 1 }, "identity": "6d15a93b-fb75-4f76-aa71-85bee08af864", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 5652, "end": 6025, "line": 22, "column": 1 }, "identity": "c25ec9b0-9812-4ef7-8c9d-c962d07acf5f", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 5652, "end": 6025, "line": 22, "column": 1 }, "identity": "c25ec9b0-9812-4ef7-8c9d-c962d07acf5f", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "OCCUPANCY_UNKNOWN", "message": "object_4a4a52914ac44ca59e0f002207a7c46d / object_83cd351f0f824e0ca1bb59e4cc915115: solid occupancy is not proven clear", "severity": "warning", "identity": "4a4a5291-4ac4-4ca5-9e0f-002207a7c46d", "span": { "start": 3130, "end": 3415, "line": 14, "column": 1 } }, { "code": "OCCUPANCY_UNKNOWN", "message": "object_5ea849eaaf5b4d96b17d70c340d8b2a3 / object_669d43bbe49f49f2abdbd7f67f416589: solid occupancy is not proven clear", "severity": "warning", "identity": "5ea849ea-af5b-4d96-b17d-70c340d8b2a3", "span": { "start": 1414, "end": 1699, "line": 8, "column": 1 } }, { "code": "OCCUPANCY_UNKNOWN", "message": "object_5ea849eaaf5b4d96b17d70c340d8b2a3 / object_683145f009b04eeb8b9a651366bdfa3f: solid occupancy is not proven clear", "severity": "warning", "identity": "5ea849ea-af5b-4d96-b17d-70c340d8b2a3", "span": { "start": 1414, "end": 1699, "line": 8, "column": 1 } }, { "code": "OCCUPANCY_UNKNOWN", "message": "object_683145f009b04eeb8b9a651366bdfa3f / object_766c80935e434d8eb00b3f2c965d487c: solid occupancy is not proven clear", "severity": "warning", "identity": "683145f0-09b0-4eeb-8b9a-651366bdfa3f", "span": { "start": 1700, "end": 1985, "line": 9, "column": 1 } }, { "code": "OCCUPANCY_UNKNOWN", "message": "object_83cd351f0f824e0ca1bb59e4cc915115 / object_e64d2b6de4c14ae3862a6f94df6f7da2: solid occupancy is not proven clear", "severity": "warning", "identity": "83cd351f-0f82-4e0c-a1bb-59e4cc915115", "span": { "start": 2844, "end": 3129, "line": 13, "column": 1 } }, { "code": "OCCUPANCY_UNKNOWN", "message": "object_cc88a6428dc34859bda0f023225a1e23 / object_e64d2b6de4c14ae3862a6f94df6f7da2: solid occupancy is not proven clear", "severity": "warning", "identity": "cc88a642-8dc3-4859-bda0-f023225a1e23", "span": { "start": 2272, "end": 2557, "line": 11, "column": 1 } }, { "code": "DOOR_OPENING_UNVERIFIED", "message": "Door rest geometry is retained; no traversable aperture or movable leaf has been verified", "severity": "warning", "identity": "57ff1a84-d6fe-4b50-9080-a1d88ea4f3b7", "span": { "start": 325, "end": 633, "line": 4, "column": 1 } }, { "code": "ROOM_PROGRAM_RULE_UNVERIFIED", "severity": "warning", "identity": "7de3cdec-20ec-4f7a-9f71-d93e99b46b10", "span": null, "message": "circulation_access: circulation (hard) unknown. Some requested units or entrance routes remain unverified; no constraints were discarded [5ea849ea-af5b-4d96-b17d-70c340d8b2a3: Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}] [683145f0-09b0-4eeb-8b9a-651366bdfa3f: Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}] [e64d2b6d-e4c1-4ae3-862a-6f94df6f7da2: Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}] [83cd351f-0f82-4e0c-a1bb-59e4cc915115: Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}]" }, { "code": "ROOM_PROGRAM_RULE_UNVERIFIED", "severity": "warning", "identity": "7de3cdec-20ec-4f7a-9f71-d93e99b46b10", "span": null, "message": "access_meeting_seats: access (hard) unknown. Some requested units or entrance routes remain unverified; no constraints were discarded [5ea849ea-af5b-4d96-b17d-70c340d8b2a3: Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}] [683145f0-09b0-4eeb-8b9a-651366bdfa3f: Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}] [e64d2b6d-e4c1-4ae3-862a-6f94df6f7da2: Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}] [83cd351f-0f82-4e0c-a1bb-59e4cc915115: Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}]" }, { "code": "PLANNER_WARNING", "message": "WRIGHT_SOURCE_CONTEXT_ENDPOINT: context relation ignored because endpoint kinds are incompatible" }, { "code": "BENCH_INTENT_NOT_CERTIFIED", "message": "per-seat presentation visibility" }, { "code": "BENCH_INTENT_NOT_CERTIFIED", "message": "per-seat egress clearance" } ], "message": "WRIGHT_SOURCE_CONTEXT_ENDPOINT: context relation ignored because endpoint kinds are incompatible", "expected": "renderable-valid-world", "expected_behavior_verified": null, "expected_behavior_review": null, "errors": [], "seconds": 27.162, "generationOutcome": "UNRESOLVED", "failureCategory": "unsupported requested constraint" }