{ "version": "wq.result/1", "scoringVersion": "wq.scoring/3", "caseId": "room-001-office-v3", "runId": "2026-09-16T12-19-48-894Z-planner-development", "mode": "planner", "status": "UNRESOLVED", "metrics": { "parse_success": true, "semantic_plan_valid": true, "requested_rooms_created": true, "requested_room_count_preserved": true, "requested_objects_present": true, "topology_valid": true, "portals_usable": true, "circulation_valid": false, "objects_grounded": true, "major_collisions": 0, "collision_scope": "independent resolved all-pairs geometry", "requested_relations_satisfied": true, "requested_dimensions_preserved": null, "constraints_not_certified": [], "constraints_dropped": null, "required_program_obligations_satisfied": false, "required_program_obligations": 10, "structured_programs_preserved": true, "structured_constraints_dropped": 0, "constraint_preservation_scope": "Exact multiset of accepted structured RoomProgram intents; not a proof of natural-language completeness", "semantic_enrichment_repairs": [ { "room": "fa43a041-67bd-4b8f-a8a3-ad49deda4cd4", "record": { "stage": "semantic", "attempts": 1, "strategy": "none", "initialFailures": [], "finalState": "accepted", "relaxedConstraints": [] } } ], "semantic_interpretation_repair": { "stage": "semantic", "attempts": 1, "strategy": "none", "initialFailures": [], "finalState": "accepted", "relaxedConstraints": [] }, "deterministic_layout_searches": [ { "room": "fa43a041-67bd-4b8f-a8a3-ad49deda4cd4", "record": { "policy": "qway.room-program-layout/1", "strategy": "bounded-geometric-search", "candidateBudget": 2048, "candidatesTested": 1020, "passesPerformed": 3, "initialRules": [ { "reference": "seat_work_seats", "status": "unknown" }, { "reference": "align_shelves", "status": "failed" }, { "reference": "circulation_access", "status": "unsupported" }, { "reference": "access_desks", "status": "unsupported" }, { "reference": "access_work_seats", "status": "unsupported" }, { "reference": "access_shelves", "status": "unsupported" } ], "changedInstances": [ "0a721bcc-e3b5-4770-9a99-1eac8387875b", "37e1eaff-e6fd-40b0-8e74-0e197e27fde2", "8898d493-64bc-4ce0-8c55-90756390c9b7", "99dbecd3-a9e0-4549-8292-93c852254638", "df84bcc6-bd3b-48f8-940f-ccdd9e0d833f", "eb449eef-ca05-482b-a4c5-4f93b2f557f9" ], "relaxedConstraints": [], "termination": "stationary" } } ], "declared_relaxations": [], "repair_count": null, "repair_telemetry": "Semantic interpretation/enrichment attempts and deterministic candidates are separate records when available; no invented aggregate unit", "visual_capture_success": true, "visual_review": "pending", "rendered_objects": 14, "room_count": 1, "unknown_collision_pairs": 1 }, "missingRooms": [], "missingObjects": [], "missingNeeds": [], "unverifiedProgramObligations": [ { "room": "fa43a041-67bd-4b8f-a8a3-ad49deda4cd4", "reference": "circulation_access", "field": "rules", "kind": "circulation", "priority": "required", "required": true, "status": "unknown", "evidence": { "reference": "circulation_access", "kind": "circulation", "priority": "required", "strength": "hard", "status": "unknown", "message": "Some requested units or entrance routes remain unverified; no constraints were discarded", "pairs": [ { "subject": "eb449eef-ca05-482b-a4c5-4f93b2f557f9", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: no-grid-route, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} }, { "subject": "df84bcc6-bd3b-48f8-940f-ccdd9e0d833f", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, no-grid-route. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} }, { "subject": "8898d493-64bc-4ce0-8c55-90756390c9b7", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, no-grid-route. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} }, { "subject": "99dbecd3-a9e0-4549-8292-93c852254638", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, no-grid-route, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} }, { "subject": "37e1eaff-e6fd-40b0-8e74-0e197e27fde2", "target": null, "status": "satisfied", "message": "Verified conservative actor route to the policy-defined use approach; not manipulation, seat-height or full ergonomic certification", "residuals": { "routeLengthM": 1.09095803413751, "actorRadiusM": 0.25, "actorHeightM": 1.8 } } ] } }, { "room": "fa43a041-67bd-4b8f-a8a3-ad49deda4cd4", "reference": "access_desks", "field": "rules", "kind": "access", "priority": "required", "required": true, "status": "unknown", "evidence": { "reference": "access_desks", "kind": "access", "priority": "required", "strength": "hard", "status": "unknown", "message": "Some requested units or entrance routes remain unverified; no constraints were discarded", "pairs": [ { "subject": "eb449eef-ca05-482b-a4c5-4f93b2f557f9", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: no-grid-route, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} }, { "subject": "df84bcc6-bd3b-48f8-940f-ccdd9e0d833f", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, no-grid-route. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} } ] } }, { "room": "fa43a041-67bd-4b8f-a8a3-ad49deda4cd4", "reference": "access_work_seats", "field": "rules", "kind": "access", "priority": "required", "required": true, "status": "unknown", "evidence": { "reference": "access_work_seats", "kind": "access", "priority": "required", "strength": "hard", "status": "unknown", "message": "Some requested units or entrance routes remain unverified; no constraints were discarded", "pairs": [ { "subject": "8898d493-64bc-4ce0-8c55-90756390c9b7", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, no-grid-route. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} }, { "subject": "99dbecd3-a9e0-4549-8292-93c852254638", "target": null, "status": "unknown", "message": "Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, no-grid-route, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.", "residuals": {} } ] } } ], "programPreservation": [ { "reference": "new_1", "room": "fa43a041-67bd-4b8f-a8a3-ad49deda4cd4", "status": "preserved" } ], "failedRelations": [], "warnings": [ { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 327, "end": 635, "line": 4, "column": 1 }, "identity": "e2bde41e-e6c4-468c-980d-d93a529b8e54", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 327, "end": 635, "line": 4, "column": 1 }, "identity": "e2bde41e-e6c4-468c-980d-d93a529b8e54", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 844, "end": 1133, "line": 6, "column": 1 }, "identity": "eb449eef-ca05-482b-a4c5-4f93b2f557f9", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 1134, "end": 1423, "line": 7, "column": 1 }, "identity": "df84bcc6-bd3b-48f8-940f-ccdd9e0d833f", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 1424, "end": 1713, "line": 8, "column": 1 }, "identity": "8898d493-64bc-4ce0-8c55-90756390c9b7", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 1714, "end": 2003, "line": 9, "column": 1 }, "identity": "99dbecd3-a9e0-4549-8292-93c852254638", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 2004, "end": 2313, "line": 10, "column": 1 }, "identity": "37e1eaff-e6fd-40b0-8e74-0e197e27fde2", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 2004, "end": 2313, "line": 10, "column": 1 }, "identity": "37e1eaff-e6fd-40b0-8e74-0e197e27fde2", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 2314, "end": 2607, "line": 11, "column": 1 }, "identity": "0a721bcc-e3b5-4770-9a99-1eac8387875b", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 2314, "end": 2607, "line": 11, "column": 1 }, "identity": "0a721bcc-e3b5-4770-9a99-1eac8387875b", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 2608, "end": 2900, "line": 12, "column": 1 }, "identity": "bd36ecb9-0165-4efc-97ff-57bca09b7dec", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 2608, "end": 2900, "line": 12, "column": 1 }, "identity": "bd36ecb9-0165-4efc-97ff-57bca09b7dec", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "SIZE_CLASSIFICATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "Sizing retained conservative measured dimensions; inspect profile confidence and dimension reference", "span": { "start": 2608, "end": 2900, "line": 12, "column": 1 }, "identity": "bd36ecb9-0165-4efc-97ff-57bca09b7dec", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 2901, "end": 3201, "line": 13, "column": 1 }, "identity": "1892ba4b-7e36-4ad1-be77-2b27bcd542bc", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 2901, "end": 3201, "line": 13, "column": 1 }, "identity": "1892ba4b-7e36-4ad1-be77-2b27bcd542bc", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 3202, "end": 3503, "line": 14, "column": 1 }, "identity": "c0cf2751-dd44-4ad0-9302-91df46f6cafa", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 3202, "end": 3503, "line": 14, "column": 1 }, "identity": "c0cf2751-dd44-4ad0-9302-91df46f6cafa", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 3504, "end": 3804, "line": 15, "column": 1 }, "identity": "b99d1646-b31c-4e1a-8911-d84f9de4c4f5", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 3504, "end": 3804, "line": 15, "column": 1 }, "identity": "b99d1646-b31c-4e1a-8911-d84f9de4c4f5", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 3805, "end": 4176, "line": 16, "column": 1 }, "identity": "9bb71690-7453-4c3f-be94-39fac847957e", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 3805, "end": 4176, "line": 16, "column": 1 }, "identity": "9bb71690-7453-4c3f-be94-39fac847957e", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 4177, "end": 4549, "line": 17, "column": 1 }, "identity": "49717b85-21b7-451a-9b18-e0965d4758f2", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 4177, "end": 4549, "line": 17, "column": 1 }, "identity": "49717b85-21b7-451a-9b18-e0965d4758f2", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "up-uncertain: retained accepted import frame", "span": { "start": 4550, "end": 4923, "line": 18, "column": 1 }, "identity": "0e3d0346-66fd-4eb3-856d-625da42712fe", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "ORIENTATION_UNCERTAIN", "message": "front-uncertain: preserved remaining authored heading", "span": { "start": 4550, "end": 4923, "line": 18, "column": 1 }, "identity": "0e3d0346-66fd-4eb3-856d-625da42712fe", "severity": "warning" }, { "code": "OCCUPANCY_UNKNOWN", "message": "object_eb449eefca05482ba4c54f93b2f557f9 / object_df84bcc6bd3b48f8940fccdd9e0d833f: solid occupancy is not proven clear", "severity": "warning", "identity": "eb449eef-ca05-482b-a4c5-4f93b2f557f9", "span": { "start": 844, "end": 1133, "line": 6, "column": 1 } }, { "code": "DOOR_OPENING_UNVERIFIED", "message": "Door rest geometry is retained; no traversable aperture or movable leaf has been verified", "severity": "warning", "identity": "e2bde41e-e6c4-468c-980d-d93a529b8e54", "span": { "start": 327, "end": 635, "line": 4, "column": 1 } }, { "code": "ROOM_PROGRAM_RULE_UNVERIFIED", "severity": "warning", "identity": "fa43a041-67bd-4b8f-a8a3-ad49deda4cd4", "span": null, "message": "circulation_access: circulation (hard) unknown. Some requested units or entrance routes remain unverified; no constraints were discarded [eb449eef-ca05-482b-a4c5-4f93b2f557f9: Bounded same-room route unverified: no-grid-route, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}] [df84bcc6-bd3b-48f8-940f-ccdd9e0d833f: Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, no-grid-route. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}] [8898d493-64bc-4ce0-8c55-90756390c9b7: Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, no-grid-route. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}] [99dbecd3-a9e0-4549-8292-93c852254638: Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, no-grid-route, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}]" }, { "code": "ROOM_PROGRAM_RULE_UNVERIFIED", "severity": "warning", "identity": "fa43a041-67bd-4b8f-a8a3-ad49deda4cd4", "span": null, "message": "access_desks: access (hard) unknown. Some requested units or entrance routes remain unverified; no constraints were discarded [eb449eef-ca05-482b-a4c5-4f93b2f557f9: Bounded same-room route unverified: no-grid-route, blocked-target, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}] [df84bcc6-bd3b-48f8-940f-ccdd9e0d833f: Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, no-grid-route. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}]" }, { "code": "ROOM_PROGRAM_RULE_UNVERIFIED", "severity": "warning", "identity": "fa43a041-67bd-4b8f-a8a3-ad49deda4cd4", "span": null, "message": "access_work_seats: access (hard) unknown. Some requested units or entrance routes remain unverified; no constraints were discarded [8898d493-64bc-4ce0-8c55-90756390c9b7: Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, blocked-target, no-grid-route. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}] [99dbecd3-a9e0-4549-8292-93c852254638: Bounded same-room route unverified: blocked-target, no-grid-route, blocked-target. Search failure is not proof of impossibility.; residuals={}]" }, { "code": "WRIGHT_CIRCULATION_UNRESOLVED", "severity": "warning", "identity": "fa43a041-67bd-4b8f-a8a3-ad49deda4cd4", "span": null, "message": "Bounded same-floor actor circulation unresolved; 0/9 interior samples reachable. Outcomes: blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target, blocked-target. An exhausted search is not proof of impossibility." }, { "code": "PLANNER_WARNING", "message": "WRIGHT_SOURCE_CONTEXT_ENDPOINT: context relation ignored because endpoint kinds are incompatible" }, { "code": "PLANNER_WARNING", "message": "WRIGHT_SOURCE_CONTEXT_ENDPOINT: context relation ignored because endpoint kinds are incompatible" } ], "message": "WRIGHT_SOURCE_CONTEXT_ENDPOINT: context relation ignored because endpoint kinds are incompatible; WRIGHT_SOURCE_CONTEXT_ENDPOINT: context relation ignored because endpoint kinds are incompatible", "expected": "renderable-valid-world", "expected_behavior_verified": null, "expected_behavior_review": null, "errors": [], "seconds": 31.432, "generationOutcome": "UNRESOLVED", "failureCategory": "portal/circulation failure" }