Impossible circulation

All examples

FAIL · conflicting

The dining room measures 2m by 2m. Twelve places surround its table. All sides require 1.5m circulation. Create it without relaxing those requirements.

Actual Studio result for this prompt

prompt.txt · generated.qway · generated.wright.json · result.json · diagnostics.json · assets.json · project.json · run.json

Metrics and limitations

{
  "version": "wq.result/1",
  "scoringVersion": "wq.scoring/3",
  "caseId": "conflict-001-dining-v3",
  "runId": "2026-09-16T12-41-18-021Z-planner-regression",
  "mode": "planner",
  "status": "FAIL",
  "metrics": {
    "parse_success": true,
    "semantic_plan_valid": false,
    "requested_rooms_created": false,
    "requested_room_count_preserved": false,
    "requested_objects_present": true,
    "topology_valid": false,
    "portals_usable": null,
    "circulation_valid": null,
    "objects_grounded": null,
    "major_collisions": 0,
    "collision_scope": "compiler diagnostics; not an all-pairs certification",
    "requested_relations_satisfied": null,
    "requested_dimensions_preserved": false,
    "constraints_not_certified": [
      "explicit 1.5m perimeter clearance"
    ],
    "constraints_dropped": null,
    "required_program_obligations_satisfied": null,
    "required_program_obligations": 0,
    "structured_programs_preserved": null,
    "structured_constraints_dropped": null,
    "constraint_preservation_scope": "Exact multiset of accepted structured RoomProgram intents; not a proof of natural-language completeness",
    "semantic_enrichment_repairs": [],
    "semantic_interpretation_repair": null,
    "deterministic_layout_searches": [],
    "declared_relaxations": [],
    "repair_count": null,
    "repair_telemetry": "Semantic interpretation/enrichment attempts and deterministic candidates are separate records when available; no invented aggregate unit",
    "visual_capture_success": true,
    "visual_review": "pending",
    "rendered_objects": 0,
    "room_count": 0
  },
  "missingRooms": [
    "dining"
  ],
  "missingObjects": [],
  "missingNeeds": [],
  "unverifiedProgramObligations": [],
  "programPreservation": [],
  "failedRelations": [],
  "warnings": [
    {
      "code": "BENCH_INTENT_NOT_CERTIFIED",
      "message": "explicit 1.5m perimeter clearance"
    }
  ],
  "message": "Error: WRIGHT_INTERPRETATION_FAILED",
  "expected": "UNRESOLVED",
  "expected_behavior_verified": false,
  "expected_behavior_review": "Manual requirement-linked contradiction review required; a timeout or unrelated layout failure is not proof",
  "errors": [],
  "seconds": 26.967,
  "generationOutcome": "FAIL",
  "failureCategory": "planner space/purpose failure"
}

Replay: from repository root run node wq-bench/replay.mjs --case conflict-001-dining-v3. A world pack is runtime-only; source plus dependency pins is the authoring example. No RIDLEY functionality is scored.